Government Can’t Fix Healthcare
- Articles, Blog

Government Can’t Fix Healthcare


Why is the government so bad at healthcare? They’ve been at it for seventy-five years
and still can’t get it right. It’s expensive. Access is spotty. It’s mired in bureaucracy. And it’s fraught with waste. Obamacare was supposed to fix all this, but
instead, like every other government healthcare program before it, it just made things worse. Why? Because the government is a third-party payer. Let me explain. Suppose you are going to buy something for
yourself. You have two priorities: price and quality. You want the highest quality for the lowest
possible price. Say you’re buying a television. You have many options: the size of the screen,
the quality of the image, the price. Only you know which one best suits your needs
and your budget. And a lot of companies are competing for your
business. You do your research; you make your choice. This is called a first-party purchase – the
person paying is the person using. Now, let’s suppose that either the price
or quality is not controlled by you; in this case, you are buying something for someone
else. You care about the price because you are paying
for it, but you are a little more flexible on the quality. A good example would be a wedding gift – say,
a coffee maker. You might think, by the time it breaks they’ll
forget who gave it to them anyway… the cheaper one will be fine. All of us have bought things for others we
never would have bought for ourselves. We care about the price because we’re paying
for it, but not so much about the quality because we’re not going to use it. Or, suppose that we’re going to use something,
but we’re not going to pay for it. Then we’re concerned about the quality because
we’re consuming it, but the cost is not as important because we’re not paying for
it. Any father who ever got roped into paying
for an open bar at a wedding understands this program. Nobody ever orders the cheap stuff when it’s
free. These are called second-party purchases. The person paying is not the person using. And now, for the coup de grace: when it is
not your money paying for something, AND you don’t use it. Then you’re not concerned about either the
price or the quality. Suppose the boss gives you $150 to buy a door
prize for the office party. In a store window, you see a six-foot tall
stuffed frog marked $149.00 You think, Oh, that’s perfect – let’s buy it. The raffle winner is awarded the six-foot
frog. Everyone laughs at the gag. Now, this is called a third-party purchase
– a purchase that is made with money that is not yours (therefore you don’t care about
the cost) to buy something you’re not going to consume (therefore you don’t care about
the quality). Here’s the point: By definition, all government
purchases are third-party purchases. The government spends other people’s money
on things it won’t consume. It doesn’t care about the price or the quality. Thus, there will always be waste in government
spending. That is why, to paraphrase Abraham Lincoln,
government should do only those things that a man can’t do better for himself. If 300 million Americans were free to buy
health insurance for themselves, just as they buy their own life and home and car insurance,
then that little gecko on television would offer us health insurance with a little more
coverage for a little less cost. And he wouldn’t be the only one. Insurance companies and hospitals would be
working night and day to get our business. Quality would go up, and prices would go down. It’s already happened with laser eye surgery. It used to cost $2,200 per eye. Now it can cost as low as $500 per eye. That’s the way free enterprise competition
works…every time. But when the government gets involved, costs
go up, waste and fraud go up, essential medical services are denied or unavailable. These are the hallmarks of government healthcare
bureaucracies around the globe. The sooner we make health insurance a first-party
purchase again, the sooner Americans will get the health care they want…finally. I’m Bob McEwen for Prager University.

About Bill McCormick

Read All Posts By Bill McCormick

2 thoughts on “Government Can’t Fix Healthcare

  1. It's interesting watching this as a Brit with our ambivalent relationship with our own NHS. Many of us love the idea of the NHS and think the nurses are angels, while still having horror stories about the lack of funding and bureaucratic incompetence that mean the standard of healthcare can often be quite poor.

    Unfortunately, any serious thought about how to improve it isn't going to happen any time soon, as it's the favourite way for politicians to gain cheap points; look at Boris Johnson's infamous Brexit pledge to give the 350m per week we give to the EU to the NHS instead (I am in favour of Brexit, and I consider that particular idea to be disingenuous to the point of an outright lie). For the foreseeable future, it would be political suicide to even suggest introducing private payment for healthcare, occasionally people float the idea of self-inflicted injuries (like extreme sports injuries or lifelong smokers who get cancer) being forced to pay, but it never gets anywhere.

    Since I've heard conflicting stories from Americans about the actual standard of healthcare given for the amount they charge for health insurance, I'm not sure I'd advocate replacing the NHS with private health insurance, I just wish people would actually give it some serious thought rather than use it as ammunition to destroy a rival.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *